About Tuna
by Luka
Tuna is an extremely popular outdoor food, but unforTUNAtely, it comes with a few problems.
Many tuna stocks are under pressure from high global demand and industrial fishing. Poorly regulated or destructive fishing practices can also result in bycatch, affecting dolphins, sharks, turtles, and other marine animals. These problems aren’t unique to tuna, though. What makes tuna particularly interesting — and problematic — is where it sits in the marine food web.
Eating high on the food chain is inefficient
Tuna are large, long-lived predators. Very simply speaking they feed on smaller fish such as herring and mackerel, which in turn feed on zooplankton, which feed on phytoplankton — the primary producers at the base of the marine food web1.
At each step up the food chain, most of the energy contained in the food is lost, mainly through metabolism and other life processes. A common rule of thumb is that only around 10% of the energy makes it into the next trophic level.
So, very roughly:
1,000 kg phytoplankton → 100 kg zooplankton → 10 kg herring → 1 kg tuna
The exact numbers vary enormously in real ecosystems, but the basic principle remains: the higher up the food chain we eat, the more primary production was needed to produce that food.
This also turns the old “vegetarians eat my food’s food” joke on its head. If you eat 1 kg of soy directly instead of feeding that soy to an animal and then eating the animal, you avoid losing most of its energy along the way. That means: producing 1 kg of animal biomass might require several kilograms of feed. So you can tell your uncle at the next family gathering:
“Thanks to me eating tofu, there’s actually more food left for your food.” ;)
Top predators keep ecosystems in balance
There is another, arguably more important, reason to think twice about removing large predators from an ecosystem. Top predators don’t just consume other animals — they help regulate the populations below them. If there is less tuna, fewer herring are hunted, so their population grows. The larger herring population then consumes more zooplankton, reducing their population. This, in turn, has not only an effect on the zooplanton, but also on phytoplankton, as well as on other organisms that interact with phytoplankton or eat zooplankton. Removing large numbers of tuna can therefore dramatically alter relationships throughout the food web. Changes at one trophic level can cascade through several others, potentially affecting many different species. These effects are known as trophic cascades2.
In other words, losing a top predator isn’t simply a matter of having fewer tuna. It can change the balance of the entire ecosystem (About cascading effects)
And then there’s mercury
Tuna is Being high up the food chain has another consequence: bioaccumulation. Mercury from the marine environment accumulates in organisms and becomes increasingly concentrated as you move up the food chain. Large, long-lived predatory fish such as tuna can therefore contain relatively high levels of mercury. For most healthy adults, eating tuna occasionally is generally fine, but frequent consumption is not recommended3.
Eat lower on the food chain
So, a useful rule of thumb is: Eat low on the food chain. A plant-based diet generally requires fewer resources than producing animal foods. But if you do want to relinquish from eating fish, choosing smaller, shorter-lived fish lower on the food chain can be a much more sustainable option than choosing large predators such as tuna.
And if you really want some fish in your outdoor food, why not take sardines? They provide protein, omega-3 fatty acids, and other nutrients too, while occupying a much lower position in the food web4. Plus, they’re way fishier. :D Here’s a potential recipe: Spaghetti a la Puttanesca.



Comments
Thanks! It'll appear once a team member approves it.